Skip to content

Methodology

How we decide what counts

Based on verified decisions and records from official public sources and documentation provided by relevant parties.
About this dataSourced records from 2020 onwards; not exhaustive.

The database covers sourced records from 2020 onwards. It is compiled from information we have been able to source, including public official records — FIFA, the Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS) and other relevant official football and judicial records — and documents or information supplied by parties or their legal representatives.

Source availability varies, and some details — such as lawyers or legal representatives, or financial amounts — may not be disclosed or available. We never invent missing data: such fields show “Not available in source” or are left blank. The dataset is not exhaustive and not every case is represented. Parties and their legal representatives may contribute additional information as the project develops.

1. Eligibility

Only established obligations qualify for a scored ranking: an order to pay contained in a decision of a competent body, or an equivalent authoritative record. Allegations, unadjudicated claims and press reports never enter the scored ranking.

  • The obligation must be adjudicated and its compliance deadline must have passed.
  • Related proceedings for the same underlying debt (e.g. an appeal confirming a first-instance decision) are linked and counted once.
  • The sporting club and the legal debtor entity are recorded separately and linked.
  • Coverage starts on 1 January 2020, global scope. The dataset is not exhaustive.

2. Scoring

ComponentPointsRule
Eligible decision issued−5Applied immediately on the decision's issue date. A decision with no registration ban still counts.
Qualifying registration ban imposed−20Added once per decision on the ban date, on top of the −5. Ban status is recorded as confirmed, confirmed no ban, or unknown — unknown is never treated as no ban.
Continuing default−1 / dayFrom the ban date when a ban is confirmed; otherwise from the applicable compliance deadline after the decision.
Verified full compliance+50, then +1 / dayNegative accrual for that decision stops; it gains 50 points immediately on the verified compliance date, then 1 point per day, until its balance reaches zero — never above zero. Partial payment does not trigger recovery.
Ban no longer on the FIFA listComplianceWhen a successful, complete FIFA list no longer shows a ban, that ban is treated as complied with from the first such check, and the compliance rules above apply. Failed or incomplete checks never change anything. Older bans whose first absence date cannot be established only stop accruing from their last listed date, with no uplift.
Repeat-default multiplier—Undecided. Not applied.

Every decision is scored on its own and the club total is the sum. One decision can be recovering at +1/day while another remains in default at −1/day; compliance with one decision never stops deductions on another. Once full compliance with an individual decision is verified, that decision gains the compliance uplift at once, then recovers one point per day until it reaches zero. It does not erase or reset other decisions or the club’s total balance. Only a verified stay with the relevant legal effect pauses accrual — filing an appeal or requesting grounds does not. Related procedural decisions on the same debt are linked and counted once.

Examples: a decision followed by a ban, after 30 days in default from the ban date: −5 −20 −30 = −55. A decision with no confirmed ban, 30 days after its compliance deadline: −5 −30 = −35.

Seasons and periods. Seasons are calendar years. Each decision is allocated to the season in which it was issued, whatever the date of the underlying dispute or ban. Period points are the movements dated inside the window (2026 Season: 1 Jan – 31 Dec 2026; 2025 Season; Last 3 Years: from 1 Jan 2024; Last 5 Years: from 1 Jan 2022; All Time: from 1 Jan 2020); events outside the window do not count. All-Time Points, shown alongside, is the separate cumulative total from 1 January 2020. Seasons are closed only by an administrator after 31 December; a closed season is frozen in an immutable published snapshot. Day counting: the daily −1 starts the day after the default start date and includes the display date.

Dates and FIFA registration bans. Dates are never guessed. The FIFA registration-ban list does not publish a decision issue date, so for that dataset the FIFA ban effective date is used as the decision date for season attribution and counting — it is not a separately published decision issue date. On that date the entry records −5 (decision) and −20 (ban), and −1 per day runs from the following day. Each distinct listed entry counts once; exact repeats of the same row are removed on import. A ban entry is not proof of a separate financial decision and is never merged with separately sourced FIFA or CAS financial decisions. A verified lift is treated as the verified compliance date for that entry. Records without any source date stay undated and are flagged for review.

Every movement is kept in a per-decision points ledger derived from the source dates and methodology version, so recalculation is reproducible and never applies the −5 or −20 twice. Published snapshots and closed seasons are frozen and never rewritten. Feed allegations never enter scores.

3. Statuses

Public compliance status is one of three values. Procedural status (final, appealed, stayed…) is recorded separately.

  • Outstanding — full compliance has not been verified. A case remains outstanding until it is.
  • Settled — full compliance has been verified from an authoritative or confirmed source. Settled cases remain in the archive.
  • Needs review / status unverified — we have been unable to confirm current status. Scoring continues; the case is never treated as settled.

Partial payments are recorded internally but are not a public scoring status.

4. Evidence hierarchy

  1. FIFA decisions (Football Tribunal, Disciplinary Committee) and published CAS awards.
  2. National court judgments; national association and league decisions and registers.
  3. Verified documents from parties or their professional representatives (supporting only).
  4. Secondary reporting — context only. Never sufficient on its own to qualify an unadjudicated claim.

Table definitions & official sources

  • Awaiting Compliance — the number of decisions not yet fully complied with for a club: verified adjudicated cases without verified full compliance, plus entries on FIFA's official registration-bans list with no verified lift. One ban entry = one club + ban start date + men's/women's team; exact duplicate rows are counted once. A ban entry is a decision, not necessarily a unique debt — several bans can relate to one underlying obligation, and the list does not say which.
  • Base amount — the principal or base compensation established by the decision, supported by evidence. It excludes interest that may keep accruing until full compliance and is not the total currently payable (decision text, CAS award, or verified documents from legal practitioners or players). The FIFA list publishes no amounts, so these show “Not published”. Unknown amounts are stored as empty, never zero or estimated.
  • Last checked — for manually verified records, the date an editor last confirmed status. For official-list entries, the date the list was actually imported or checked (“Source last checked”). It is never set to today just because the page is opened.
  • Status caveat — a club appears as outstanding because it is on the list as of the source check date. A listed ban stops counting only once its lift is verified.
  • Provenance — each import records publisher, file name, import/check date, rows in file and rows imported. Later amounts and decision details supplied with evidence are added by editors, carry a verification status, and every change is written to the audit log.

5. Verification cycle

Each month, editors prepare status-confirmation requests to the creditor or their representative and to the debtor club. Requests are logged; nothing is sent automatically. If there is no response within 3–5 days the case is flagged “awaiting confirmation” for review — silence never marks a case settled.

6. Caveats

  • Unknown amounts are shown as “Not verified”, never as zero. Different currencies are never converted or summed.
  • Many decisions are not public; absence from this database is not evidence of compliance.
  • Creditor identities are anonymised. We do not publish private documents or internal notes.
  • Registration bans come from a published ban list that gives the ban start date but not the decision issue date, creditor or amount; those fields show “Not available in source”. Fixed-length bans are treated as active until a lift is verified.
  • Coverage: sourced records from 2020 onwards. The dataset is not exhaustive and not every case is represented; fields a source does not provide are shown as “Not available in source”.
  • Registration-ban counts are imported from FIFA's published ban list. Ban amounts and creditors are not available in that source, and the FIFA ban effective date is used as the decision date for season attribution.
  • Three separate labels are kept apart: the sanctioning body (who decided — FIFA, CAS, a national tribunal or other), the source / provider (who supplied the information — FIFA, a legal representative, player, coach, creditor club or other) and the debt type (what the obligation was). A debt type is shown only where evidence supports it; otherwise it is “Unverified financial basis” or left blank.
  • A club stays in the financial classification unless reliable evidence establishes that its sanction was imposed for a separate non-financial breach. Allegations, investigations or a registration ban alone do not establish such a breach.

7. Corrections

Clubs, creditors and representatives can submit corrections with supporting evidence. Every change to a record is captured in an internal audit trail, and material corrections are dated on the record.

Submit a correction →